While reading this post (dated Feb 2 2011), for the first few minutes I was sure I'd mistakenly stumbled upon some Vegan/Animal rights article which had inexplicably managed to sneak itself unto the Wholefoods website.
Now don't get me wrong. I have NOTHING against vegans or animal rights for that matter. I mean - to each his own. But I'm a girl who loves her meat, so any talk about the benefits of vegetarianism is totally lost on me.
But the phrase 'while shopping for meat' had caught my eye, so I pressed on. Which was lucky, since it turns out that the topic was anything but what I'd initially thought it was.
As someone who is very interested in the subject of nutrition (and considering the fact that I'm spending a great deal of money to educate myself about it) I understand what Wholefoods and it's affiliate organizations are trying to accomplish by this venture. In fact, let me say here and now that I not only understand it, I respect it. We need more chain stores to join in this effort to ensure that safe food is delivered to our tables.
Still, for once I found myself looking at things from the point of view of the animals. What struck me while I was watching the embedded video clip,
was a comment made by one of the people interviewed. He said [and I quote] - " The animals are rooting, they're playing, they're running around in a manner that <pause> you might say they're happy..."
Now that gave ME pause.
I have a confession to make. You see, I'm not an animal lover, at least not in the way most people would understand it. I never owned a pet growing up, and I don't feel that somehow my life is damaged because of it. The only time I like to have close physical contact with any animal is when it's nicely cooked and on it's way to my mouth from my plate. Still after watching that video (which by the way would have made any animal rights activist very proud) I began to think more compassionately (if I may use that word) about the animals that 'give up their happiness' so to speak and lay down their lives, just to satisfy my choosy palate.
I know it may seem like I'm trying to play devil's advocate here, given my antecedents, but I really am not. Think about it - would it be okay if you had your hair and scalp tenderly nurtured by your hairstylist for months on end, only to find out that the real reason he was putting in all that dedicated hard work was because he was planning to shave your head clean and sell your hair as extensions?!
I guess the moral of this story is that we meat lovers actually do have our moments of quiet and sober reflection. In fact after watching that video, I think I'm going to stick to fish from now on; at least until someone comes along to try to convince me that fish have emotions too!
I only have strong emotional connections to an animal or animals when I have had the opportunity to take care of them. My parents once had a little nursery for taking care of chicks and I was actively involved in feeding the chicks and cleaning out the nursery. As the chicks grew older they lost all their cuteness and I got less attached. So I guess hearing that one or two had been Slaughtered for lunch didn't really bother me. I honestly cannot give up animal flesh for anything, my taste buds come first!
ReplyDeleteAt Zee-zee -
ReplyDeleteLOL! I can totally relate...
Hmm... 'The considerate carnivore!' You take no pleasure in the slaughter but just in the results. Still when it comes to outright animal cruelty, (teasing, maiming or hurting for fun) I think it's more a reflection of a person's soul. If you deliberately torment an animal, you'll probably do the same to a human being if given the chance.
ReplyDeleteQuestion: what is the activist's stance on insects like roaches and such?
my dear I just discovered fish also have emotions, they feel pain so maybe u can change to insects lol. check it out--
ReplyDeletehttp://www.thenazareneway.com/vegetarian/fish_have_feelings.htm
@ Lopsy -
ReplyDeleteYou totally have me on that one LOL!!!
See why I don't even bother to get into these arguments about veganism/animal rights? I acn never win, and a girl's got to eat something right?
OK, I dare anyone to come up with proof that plants FEEL pain too! In fact, I hope someone does, so I'll be justified in ignoring all parties altogether (lol!)
Thanks for posting. Hmmmmm...mmm this might just be the topic of my next blog...
When I think of domesticated pets (strictly limited to dogs and cats), I can understand what it means to say animals have emotions, after all we can tell how they feel somehow. Outside this little niche, it is hard to imagine a "happy" shark or "moody". Would you want to find it out first hand? I guess not. Also mind blowing is the idea of animals having temperaments (oh yes, I heard of that too). Imagine a "melancholic" lion, taking its time to pull meticulously eat its kill.
ReplyDeleteIn all fairness, these guys who rate animal welfare should extend the scope of their "animals of interest" to include those in the wild. I guess King Mufasa would find a way to reward them.